2025
An Empirical Study on the Market-Maker and Retail Investor Performance in ETF Premium–Discount Arbitrage
Market makers, equipped with high-frequency trading capabilities, low-cost structures, and real-time creation/redemption privileges, are the primary participants in ETF premium–discount arbitrage.
In contrast, retail investors face multiple constraints—information delays, transaction fees, and taxes—which make it difficult for them to enter the market promptly or profit effectively, even when an arbitrage opportunity is detected.
Using the Yuanta Taiwan 50 ETF (0050) as an example, this study simulates the actual execution of premium–discount arbitrage by these two market participants based on historical data.
By comparing performance under varying entry/exit thresholds and cost structures—and evaluating metrics such as win rate, return distribution, and drawdown risk—we aim to clarify an essential question:In this seemingly “risk-free arbitrage,” who truly captures the opportunity and earns consistent profits?